Edgar died? OK, I know Farley died when April fell in, so I think there may be an error there...then they got Edgar in to replace Farley, which ended up being the same "furry clown" that Farley was. Then the brown-haired retriever thing (Dixie?) came in, and it wasn't much of an improvement. Butterscotch was the golden-colored rabbit to replace Mr. B, and that was presumably April's, so when April moved out, much to Flap'n'Honk's relief, took April with her, leaving her to live out the rest of Edgar and Dixie. Since Elly and John were never big pet owners, while not straight-up abusing the dogs, they probably could've lasted longer if Elly and John had treated them better. Farley died in 1995, so Edgar came in circa 1996. Add twenty years to be 2016, but Edgar probably didn't last that long, so he probably died after 2008.