On smoking in the Foobisphere.
Dec. 23rd, 2009 12:32 amAs I mentioned a little while ago, Elly, Iris, Marian and Georgia share the desire to see the men in their lives quit smoking. Jim and Phil do quit for a time but, sooner or later, they return to the habit and scowl about how selfish meddlers want to deny them their link to sanity while they pretty much run around in circles and look, talk and act like a pair of junkies in high panic mode because they need a fix yesterday, man. The reason I mention this is that it's one of the things that Lynn consistently gets right; her rightness about how smokers are psychologically and chemically dependent on coffin nails even extends into the Declining Years. That being said, it seems somewhat odd that the excuse Connie uses to travel to Montréal and making a clingy chump of herself is that she "has" to return a different delivery system for Phil's favorite addictive chemical: the pipe she catches Michael and Lawrence playing with. The only thing that makes it sort of appropriate is that she's addicted to the idea of getting a man to complete her.
Elly versus her childhood.
Dec. 19th, 2009 12:42 amThe problem with taking Elly's part, as I did yesterday, is that she really doesn't seem to know How Things Work. As an example, she seems to have not noticed how buttoned-down society was in the nineteen fifties and why; not only did the victors of the Second World War want Rosie the Riveter to change back into Suzie Homemaker after the emergency situation that got her out of the kitchen was over, there were two horrors that frightened them into wanting to turn back the clock. Those demons were named International Communism, which made the average Joe fear any sort of social change, and the Hydrogen Bomb whose presence meant probable doom to all; since Jim and Marian lived as I and my parents did in the shadow of Oppenheimer's deadly toy, they wanted a safe, tidy world wherein traditional values held a certain amount of weight. This meant, of course, that little girls had to be protected from tomboyish behavior for what society at large agreed was their own good. If that meant that Elly got a bicycle later than Phil, it was sort of unfair but those were the rules. Also, the antics of little boys were shrugged off as harmless enough monkeyshines as their parents quoted the law "Boys will be boys" and "Proper young ladies should mind their manners"; the Richardses didn't set out to be jerks but it just sort of happened that way. The worst of it is that their attitudes changed too late to do any good; they knew that they'd frakked up royally and made Elly of the non-stop victimism feel unloved but couldn't do sweet Richard all about it. Since they couldn't undo her upbringing, all that was left was trying to make her adult years better.
John and the in-laws......
Apr. 25th, 2009 01:42 amI realize that this is coming out of left field here but I'd like to rehash a favorite subject of mine: trying to figure out what Jim and Marian really thought of John. It would seem to me that Marian had a higher opinion of Train Man than her husband. This is, of course, owing to her need to think that Elly can do no right; he cannot be blamed for Elly's flaking out and spoiling everyone's hopes for her. It doesn't really matter that she was so down on herself that his suggestion that she be a SAHM seemed like salvation; that's because the poor self-image that resulted from years of the corrosive bullshit we saw spewing from Great Grandma BattleAxe's mouth isn't the problem; if Elly were 'good', she'd be able to withstand an unremitting stream of verbal abuse. Jim, on the other hand, might not be so quick to see John as the ideal husband; that's because he actually did have a certain amount of faith in his daughter; in his eyes, she didn't need a keeper. Sadly, nobody else, not even Elly herself, seems to have thought that way. This, it seems, is why he was so great with April; if I'm reading the situation right, he was trying for a second chance to raise Elly. If he couldn't get the real one to have a happy life, a lookalike would have to do.
Marian the not-so-great......
Apr. 23rd, 2009 01:51 amAs we all know, Mike idolized his grandmother Marian. It's hard to see why, though. The sequence that had him wax rhapsodic about how swell a lady she was faithfully recorded her blowing him off, dumping him in a peeved Grandpa Jim's lap and enjoying her favorite past time: chewing Elly out for her imaginary inadequacies. Whenever we saw the old doll, she ran her mouth about how lazy, spoiled and immature Elly was, how her cooking and cleaning didn't measure up and how disappointed she always was in her. Her Liography said she did all that to keep Elly from being a spoiled petty tyrant; the message I got was that she did that because she was herself tyrannical and small-minded. The end result was that Elly burned herself into the ground doing pointless busywork she hated trying to please a woman who couldn't be pleased and collecting junk she didn't need so that people would take her seriously. That's, of course, because her dizzy old meataxe of a mom was the source of the Pattersons' love of needlessly complicating their lives with clutter; the only one to escape that was April who fell in with Jim's bizarre, unfoobly habit of only keeping one or two souvenirs.
The Grand Unifying Theory of Elly……
Apr. 20th, 2009 01:24 amAs you know, Elly’s behavior doesn’t seem to make much sense in real world terms if you believe that she had the bland childhood she claims to have had. It’s difficult to tie together the following odd phenomena:
- Elly does not regard Vancouver as being home but simply as where she used to live.
- Her moving thousands of miles away to Southern Ontario but never again doing anything that adventurous.
- Her desperate need to drop out of University so as to marry and have a family.
- Her constant cleaning that, for some odd reason, results in nothing getting done.
- Her obsessive fear of being harshly judged by a world that doesn’t actually care.
- Her emotional distance from those around her.
- Her constant moaning about how bad her life is.
- Her treatment of Jim in his old age.
- Her distant relationship with her brother
- Her need to have someone like Connie to feel superior to
- Her dread of motorcycles
- Her need to abolish anything that isn’t familiar and safe.
unless you assume that Elly had suffered some sort of horrible disruption in her past that she never shared with her family. In a recent blog entry. forworse put things together the only way that makes any real-world sense: she assumed that Elly had gotten pregnant when she was seventeen. It seemed likely to her that, rather than face the scandal of having their daughter be seen to be carrying someone else’s illegitimate child, acknowledge its existence or look her in the face, Jim and the others packed her off to relatives in the Toronto area where she could have the kid in secret and then stay there so they wouldn’t have to be reminded of their shame. It also explains why the Hell the old buzzard never smiled and why Elly went into convulsions when she learned that he didn’t care if Philip cohabited with Georgia. It’s not very pleasant to realize that your dad is the sort of fink who thinks that having a Y-chromosome allows you to get away with pretty much everything. It explains her depression, fear of being judged and need for safety at all costs: I should think that she lives her life still convinced that her parents were right to treat her like she wasn’t fit to live among civilized people. This self-loathing is almost as crippling as her fear that said child would one day emerge from the shadows and destroy all that she had managed to create for herself. It seems likely that even now that forty years have past, John would react negatively to being reminded that she had a past that didn’t include him; what’s more, she assumes that if people knew something that didn’t affect them in any way or was really worth mentioning, she’d be the pariah that her parents made her all over again.
Marian and Jim in the new-runs
Feb. 27th, 2009 12:55 amIt would seem that we might soon be subjected to the story arc that depicts Elly’s extended visit to her parents. I can’t quite remember the reason she did it in the original continuity but I have a fair idea of what reason will be offered this time. Simply put, Elly will have had too much work, too much time near children and too little support from her oafish boor husband to be able to cope; she’ll need to get away from her familyproblems or she’ll go nuts. This, of course, is a rather specious reason because we’ve seen that Elly deliberately piles on the work as a means of getting attention and sympathy. What’s more, her parents know her well enough to see what she’s up to. They go so far as to remind her what an immature, selfish little fool she is. This, of course, is meant to show them as being blind and mean-spirited clods who don’t know or care how hard her life is. Unfortunately for Lynn, her attempt to make them bad people will end up making them folk heroes. It doesn’t matter how grumpy Jim is or how passive-aggressive Marian gets; since they call Elly on her BS, they’ll have a following among those who snark Foob.
- April's garage band breaking up so she concentrate on her studies with the understanding that she will eventually marry her Twoo Wuv Gerald.
- Michael becoming a best selling author worried about becoming too big for his britches.
- Deanna balancing a career and motherhood.
- Liz and Anthony settling down to more or less become the new Elly and John.
- Jim and Iris spending their last years in an assisted living facility.
and
- John and Elly seeing Jim's poor health as a reminder that one day, one of them will have to take care of the other.
Since she gave herself an extra year, she had to find some way to force people's story lines back to the conclusion she'd decided on. To that end, we had the business last spring where April and Gerald had a spat over his touring with Evil Becky, the Blood Cargo ego-fest and more strips with Dee being gobsmacked. This is also why Jim had a second stroke. That way, his health problems would still be fresh in people's minds so they could believe in Lynn's attempts to revisit the recent past just as much as they do her rehashing the distant past.
Elly : Failed Caretaker
Jul. 25th, 2008 12:25 am![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
Anthony, Therese and Jim.
Mar. 29th, 2008 07:33 amJim, Iris and the Miracle Dress.
Mar. 28th, 2008 07:46 amMira and Jim and John and Deanna.....
Jan. 27th, 2008 07:57 am- Why does a daugher she raised to seek out the best in everything buy second hand goods for her children?
- Why did she live in a series of rathole apartments?
- Why is she treading water financially when she was brought up to be careful with her money?
- Why does the bright, cheerful young woman who went to Honduras look like a carbon copy of the shouting idiot she calls a mother-in-law?
All these horrible questions have a horrible answer: the selfish creep she'd married is draining the life out of her. As far as Mira can see, the daydreaming slacker sits on his fat ass pretending that he's a big time author thereby forcing Deanna to wear herself out to support him. This, to her, is a terrible thing because she could have married a better man and had a better life. The only real problem with that line of reasoning is that Deanna wants to do this. She, for reasons that make sense to her, refuses the life her mother had planned for her. Not for her the understanding that Mom thinks that she has to be twice as good as everyone else just to be accepted. Everything we know about Deanna tells us that she wants nothing to do with the overly-structured life her mother values. She's willing to endure a few minor inconveniences in the name of a slower life. She clearly thinks that once things settle down, she'll have the quiet, tidy life she thinks that the Pattersons have. To sum up, she knows she can do the things her Mom wants her to, she just doesn't want to.
This sort of contrasts her with her role model, Elly. As we've seen over the years, our hero complains non-stop about the potential she's wasting raising children and cleaning house. What's more, Jim was always right in there mourning the loss of the great contribution she made to society, always seemingly ready to blame John and his selfish habit of keeping his child from excelling for her constant unhappiness. He, too, would do so in vain because Elly was not really serious about wanting her degree. She wanted a husband, kids and a home to care for and she wanted to complain about having them because she's only happy when she's upset and getting everyone else wound up. I remember most of the strips from the early years and she wasn't talking about her great work never being accomplished. She wanted to hear adult voices that talked about things she might care about and that was that.
Elly and Jim: a theory.
Jan. 24th, 2008 07:35 amAfter Jim: An impact assessment......
Dec. 30th, 2007 07:57 amIris: Jim would be the second husband she'd have lost within the space of about five years and that would, of course, devastate her. She'd spend the rest of her life wondering if she did enough. Or, as far as that goes, the right thing. I'd say she'd have an awful thing to wish for -- that the man not have been aware of what was happening.
Elly: She'd turn on Iris in a Milborough minute. The same woman who was an adequate care-giver when her dad was alive would be a hopeless incompetent before he'd entered full rigor. We could also look forward to her being a shit about any will Jim might have written.
John: He'd make some pompous remark about how the man died because he didn't act his age. According to the Train Douche, having fun in public kills.
Mike: We could well expect him to somehow try to promote his book, anout how Jim hung around just long enough to see his favorite (and only) grandson become a success.
Deanna: She'd spout some chirpy, trippy-sounding pile of mush about birds and flowers to hide the fact that she didn't know the man from Adam.
Liz: She'd manage to upstage his disgusting brother and boring old dead guy by announcing that she wasn't going to waste any more time: she was going to marry Anthony.
April: The only other person who'd miss Jim if he were gone. Too bad her family wouldn't let her grieve. If she wasn't stuck home with the Patterspawn, they'd accuse her of trying to ruin his funeral for everyone by calling Liz on letting her stalker get away with swiping Jim's harmonica because he spouted some phony flattery.
House of Distractions.....
Dec. 20th, 2007 07:53 am1) The Housening. It seems to me and to a lot of people that it would have taken a matter of weeks to find Mike, Deanna and their kids an acceptable hoooooooooome, no matter how pooooooor they were. Instead, they hung around like a bad smell so Deanna and John could manipulate everyone into the domestic arrangement that suited them. All it took was making April feel like a piece of crap but in an odd way, they did her a good turn. She can't really rely on having the 'rents look out for her after she hits eighteen because they'll be barely getting by themselves because they're stupid with their money.
2) The Settlepocalypse. The time not spent worrying about overcrowding and who was going to have to give up what was wasted stressing on Liz and her pointless issues. Fretting about her and her fellow obsessive and the havoc they wreak on the world seems to me to be an exercise in futility. Like it or not, people like her and Awfulny just seem to get stuck with one another and there's little we can do about it.
What makes things worse is that it could be that this was done deliberately in order to not have to face things. Elly, you see, fears being dependent on other people. Her idea of horror is being in the position her dad is in now. If she avoids him, shuts him out of her heart, she can pretend that it might not happen to her.